Is Real Estate a Good Investment? (Part 2)
This is the second part of a two-part discussion on real estate. The first part covered buying real estate as an investment, and showed that buying individual rental properties is not an optimal investment strategy. This part covers buying real estate to live in. Before I go into the analysis, let me cover two of the most common arguments I hear for buying vs renting.
"Paying rent is just throwing money away."
How did paying for shelter turn into throwing money away? And where do you draw the line, is paying for your groceries instead of growing it yourself also throwing money away? The real consideration should be whether the costs of buying is more or less than the costs of renting. Remember, buying also has costs that add up very quickly like mortgage interest, property taxes, maintenance/repairs, home insurance, commissions, and closing costs.
Is Real Estate a Good Investment? (Part 1)
When I talk to people about investing and personal finance, the topic of real estate inevitably comes up. This is a fairly broad topic, so I have broken up the discussion into two parts: Part 1 covers buying real estate as rental property, and Part 2 covers buying real estate as a home. In both parts, when referring to "real estate" I really mean single-family residential properties.
Let’s start with long-term statistics. Home prices in the long run (50+ years) have only increased by a small amount above inflation (0.26% from 1890-2009, 0.29% from 1959-2009). And at first glance, this return looks absurdly very low versus stocks (6% after inflation) and bonds (2% after inflation). However, to make a fair comparison, we need to calculate the total return which incorporates the rental income, as well as leverage through a mortgage.






